It turned green from copper, not algae. Who would’ve thought?
Brand new pool turned green from copper
I got a text from a customer in the Northeast that just finished plastering a pool the week before. The text had a picture in it of a green pool, and it read:
My first thought was algae when I saw the color of the pool. But that thought lasted all of about 15 seconds. This was a brand new pool. The next most plausible explanation was the pool turned green from copper. Why? Because we have encountered copper before and it was the reason for a pool turning green.
Copper, when oxidized, turns green
Think of the Statue of Liberty. It is made of copper, and has turned green over time through oxidation. What accelerates oxidation? Oxidizers like chlorine. Copper was making some sense, except that the customer started up his pool using our SC-1000 sequest. In that case, copper should have been sequestered and not falling out of solution… this wasn’t making complete sense.
So I read the text again, more carefully. “Water immediately turned yellow when we added 2.5 gallons of liquid chlorine after we added 1 quart of algaecide…” What was in the algaecide?
Sure enough, the algaecide product was copper-based. Normally SC-1000 will neutralize a copper-based algaecide, but in this case, the algaecide was followed up with 2.5 gallons of liquid chlorine. I know that because I spoke with the customer on the phone about it. The chlorine was poured in moments after the algaecide.
We asked for a water test to figure out the copper level, because the next picture he texted me was this:
The homeowner started filling their pool with well water. Most of the pool was actually filled by a water truck from a local municipal water source, but this first initial amount of water clearly had a lot of metal in it. I mean…look at it. We did the math and estimate that when the well water hose was shut off and the truck took over, 1/36th of the pool was filled with the green water you see above. Could that have been enough copper to cause a problem?
Copper-based algaecide was oxidized by the chlorine shock, and turned the entire pool green
Between the fill water and the copper-based algaecide, there was enough copper to react with chlorine immediately. The reaction happened before the customer’s eyes, which I’m sure is crazy to watch. It’s also a crisis in the moment. If you have never been in that situation, can you imagine being the pool company that just turned a brand new pool green from copper? Because it got more green as the day went on…
Fixing the problem
Our SC-1000 sequesters metals, but Orenda does not have a product that removes metals from the water. Such products do exist, however. In particular, we recommended this customer use a product called CULator to capture and remove the copper from the pool water. Yes, it can be considered a competing product to SC-1000, but who cares? The customer had a problem that we alone could not fix. CULator is a solid product that doesn’t conflict with ours, and it’s exactly what was needed for the customer.
The customer combined that with several quarts of another stain & metal remover product (I forgot the name of it), plus more SC-1000. It was a blitz strategy to remove as much copper as possible, and fortunately, it worked out! Here’s the pool after 48 hours and some backwashing:
This is a valuable lesson that hopefully will never happen to you. But if it does, consider the consequences of oxidizing copper (it turns green!). There are metal test kits out there, and it would be wise to test your tap water for metal content. The more you know, the less surprises happen. If you know you have metal in your source water, consider using a MetalTrap filter when filling your pool.
Normally SC-1000 can handle metals just fine, but there was no time to stop the oxidation of that copper-based algaecide. The chlorine shock that immediately followed it set off the reaction, and the pool turned green from copper. Who would’ve thought? If you have this problem or know someone who does, feel free to contact us if you need help.